The Guilt of Taking a Break: Why Caregivers Struggle to Rest
By: Michelle Nortje
The more exhausted we become, the more we need rest and support. Caring for the carer begins with recognising that their needs matter too.
Reading up more about this awareness-building week and it’s goals, I felt struck with thinking about the many clients I see each week who take up caregiving roles – as parents, caring for elderly parents, or navigating a spouse’s mental or physical illness. What I often notice in conversations with these clients, is that even when they know all the ‘right’ self-care routines, there is often something holding them back from actually using them or from asking for help and support.
It’s important for us therefore to name the guilt that often acts as a barrier to well-being for those with high caregiving responsibilities. There might be a belief that their needs should always come second, that they should be able to manage without help, or that taking time for themselves somehow means taking something away from the person they care for. For some people, even acknowledging that they are tired or struggling can feel uncomfortable.
This article will explore some of the possible barriers to self-care and wellbeing for caregivers, and suggest ways we might continue to care for our loved ones while also caring for ourselves. One doesn’t need to preclude the other.
Why does taking a break feel so difficult?
Caregiving often involves a genuine sense of responsibility towards another person. We may feel deeply committed to the wellbeing of a child, partner or parent, and being needed can become an important part of how we understand our role in that relationship. It is therefore understandable that stepping away, even temporarily, can bring up feelings of guilt, that we are now in some way abandoning that role.
The difficulty comes when responsibility gradually becomes an expectation that we should always be available, always cope and always put our own needs aside. Thoughts that rely on all-or-nothing rules for caregiving can make it surprisingly difficult to accept help or prioritise our own wellbeing, because we then start believing that if we are not always caring, then we must somehow be doing the opposite – failing, neglecting or abandoning someone.
This can create a difficult and draining cycle. When we are continually in a role of giving, it is easy to become increasingly drained. The more exhausted we become, the more we need rest and support. Yet the more we need rest, the more guilty we may feel about taking it. We can find ourselves waiting until we are completely depleted before allowing ourselves to do something that might have helped us much earlier.
What does a “good” caregiver look like?
It can be helpful to get curious about some of the assumptions that sit underneath caregiver guilt. Perhaps for you, being a good caregiver means self-sacrifice and putting someone else’s needs before your own. Perhaps it means coping without complaining, being endlessly patient, or being the person who can always be relied upon. Perhaps asking for help feels like an admission that you are not coping as well as you should or that you have failed someone in their time of need.
These beliefs are understandable, particularly when they have developed from a genuine desire to care well for someone. However, they can also create an impossible standard. Can you hear how much pressure these thoughts might place on you as a caregiver?
It is a big perspective change to move then to suggesting that being a caring person does not mean having unlimited emotional or physical capacity, and being committed to someone does not mean being available to them every moment of the day.
There is an important difference between responsibility and total responsibility. We can take up an important responsibility to care for someone without being solely responsible for meeting every one of their needs. When caregiving becomes organised around these absolute expectations, however, it can become much harder to recognise our own limits and respond to them before exhaustion and burnout sets in.
Taking a break doesn’t mean you care less
One of the most important things we can remind caregivers is that needing a break is not evidence that they care less or have failed the person they love. It is possible to love someone deeply and still feel tired of caring. It is possible to feel grateful for a relationship while also feeling frustrated by the demands placed upon you. These experiences do not cancel each other out. This both-and approach to thinking about caregiving can free us up to have more flexibility and an expanded awareness of ourselves and our relationships with the people we care for.
This both-and approach can also create more room in the relationship itself. The person we care for is more than someone whose needs we are constantly attending to. They can still be our partner, our parent, our child, or our friend – someone with whom we can share humour, conversation, affection, interests and ordinary moments.
Caregivers can also sometimes worry that acknowledging their own needs means they are being selfish or uncaring. But needing rest is simply part of being human. We all have limits on our emotional, physical and mental capacity, and reaching those limits is not a character flaw.
Rather than asking, “What kind of person needs a break from someone they love?” it may be more helpful to ask, “What happens when someone is expected to keep giving without enough opportunity to recover and replenish their energy?” This shift can allow us to think about rest not as something that competes with caring, but as something that can sit alongside it.
What would guilt-free rest look like?
So if we try to action this both-and, more flexible way of approaching caregiving, we can see that guilt-free rest does not mean waiting until you no longer feel guilty. Sometimes the guilt will still be there when you first begin to take better care of yourself. Can you practise noticing the guilt without automatically allowing it to make the decision for you?
This might mean accepting an offer of help rather than immediately saying, “I’m fine.” It might mean taking a break before getting to the point of having nothing left to give. It could mean making space for parts of yourself that have nothing to do with your caregiving role – spending time with friends, exercising, reading, pursuing an interest, or simply sitting with a cup of coffee.
Perhaps most importantly, these changes do not need to be earned by ‘enough’ suffering or becoming sufficiently exhausted before giving yourself permission to rest. Rest does not have to be a reward for having completed everything on your caregiving list, because that list may never truly be finished.
A break is not the opposite of caring. Asking for help is not a sign that you don’t care. And taking time to be a person beyond your caregiving role does not diminish the love or responsibility you feel towards someone else.
Sometimes, caring for the carer begins with recognising that their needs matter too.
Feature image: canva.com